New UPSC Foundation, Optional and TGPSC/APPSC batches are open — book your counselling slot.Explore coursesGroup 2 crash course ₹9,999Today's Current AffairsToday's Daily QuizPlaces in NewsCall 98804 87071

Ethics & Integrity · Chapter 3 · Topic 7 of 16

Discretion and Accountability

Judgement in grey areas, with recorded reasons

Discretion

A statute may permit several lawful outcomes because no legislature can anticipate every factual variation. Accountability asks who chose, on what evidence, for which statutory purpose and with what safeguards.

There is no discretion to act outside jurisdiction, for a corrupt purpose or under an unauthorised person’s dictation.

Concept diagram

The corridor of accountable discretion

The officer writes reasons inside boundaries set by law, rights and review.

  • Authority and statutory purpose define the available corridor.
  • Hear affected parties and document why the chosen option is proportionate.

Administrative-law controls on choice

ControlOperational questionFailure signal
Jurisdiction and proper purposeDoes this authority have this power for this objective?Using licensing powers to punish political criticism.
Relevant considerationsDid the officer weigh matters the statute makes relevant?Ignoring safety reports while favouring personal connections.
Independent judgementWas the case assessed rather than decided by an outsider?Treating a political request as a binding command.
No rigid fetteringDoes policy guide cases while leaving room for legally relevant exceptions?Refusing even to consider exceptional facts despite statutory discretion.
Natural justiceWas bias avoided and an appropriate opportunity to respond provided?Cancelling a licence on undisclosed adverse material without lawful justification.
Speaking orderCan the affected person understand the decisive reasons?A bare assertion of public interest without a factual link.

Reasonableness and proportionality

Wednesbury review

  • Classically asks whether a decision is so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could have reached it.
  • Also associated with scrutiny of irrelevant considerations and omitted relevant considerations.
  • It does not ordinarily invite the judge to replace the administrator’s preferred policy with another.

Proportionality

  • Tests legitimate aim, rational connection, necessity and balancing of adverse impact against the objective.
  • A less rights-restrictive, equally effective alternative matters to necessity.
  • Modern Dental College (2016) and Puttaswamy (2017) are important Indian reference points; the applicable test depends on context.
VS

Do not reduce proportionality to a vague claim that benefits exceed costs; examine the means as well as the end.

Worked case: closing an unsafe public market

Evidence and authority

  • An inspection identifies dangerous wiring in one market wing. A councillor demands closure of every shop for a month.
  • Confirm statutory safety powers, inspection quality and whether immediate danger justifies emergency action.

Tailored action

  • Isolate the dangerous wing if technically adequate; arrange safe access and repairs. Wider closure needs evidence that narrower protection is insufficient.
  • Where immediate action lawfully precedes a hearing, record the urgency and provide prompt review or hearing as appropriate.

Accountability

  • Issue reasons, publish safe reopening criteria and inspect within a fixed period.
  • Record why the councillor’s preference was not decisive; monitor safety and livelihood effects rather than prolonging closure by inertia.

Build an accountability trail

  1. Step 1

    Before · Design the choice

    • Declare conflicts, check delegation, collect evidence and identify rights and mandatory procedures.
  2. Step 2

    During · Make the reasoning visible

    • Hear affected parties where required, compare feasible alternatives and give intelligible reasons without exposing protected information.
  3. Step 3

    After · Permit correction

    • Communicate review routes, retain records and evaluate whether the promised safeguards actually work.

Accountability is not paralysis

Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.

  • The safest decision is always no decision.

    Unexplained delay may itself be arbitrary and harmful; lawful discretion exists to be exercised.

  • A hearing guarantees permission.

    Fair procedure guarantees consideration, not the applicant’s preferred result.

  • A detailed order cures lack of jurisdiction.

    Reasons cannot create a power the authority does not possess.

Prelims focus

  • E.P. Royappa (1974): arbitrariness is antithetical to equality.
  • Audi alteram partem means hearing the other side; nemo judex addresses bias.

Mains angle

  • PYQ-style: Can wider discretion coexist with stronger accountability? Use ex ante standards, contemporaneous reasons and ex post review.
  • Use the market case to distinguish necessary emergency protection from disproportionate restriction.

Flip & recall

Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.

Practice MCQs

Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.

0 / 3 correct · 3 left

  1. Q1.Which is an example of acting under dictation?

  2. Q2.Which question most directly tests necessity in proportionality?

  3. Q3.An emergency safety order should:

Free UPSC daily current affairs quiz — 10 questions, new every day at 8 am IST.

Call nowWhatsApp