The same officer can feel compassion for an applicant, encounter pressure from a community network and face a rule requiring equal treatment. Mapping these influences reveals where a judgement comes from; constitutional scrutiny determines whether it deserves to guide public action.
Chapter 1 introduced determinants of judgement; here the task is to locate their interaction and identify points of ethical intervention.
Concept diagram
Values grow in three worlds
Family, society and education nourish values, while inner reflection and institutional conditions shape what takes root.
- Trace the roots to the fruits: sources influence values without mechanically determining them.
- Distinguish social relationships, personal reflection and institutional rules.
Three lenses, different mechanisms
| World | How it works | Strength and risk |
|---|---|---|
| Inner: person | Memory, emotions, conscience and reflection filter an experience. | Empathy can notice distress; an unexamined association can create prejudice. |
| Social: relationships | Family, peers, language, faith communities and cultural narratives communicate approval and belonging. | Solidarity supports cooperation; loyalty can become exclusion. |
| Institutional: organised systems | Schools, offices, laws, incentives and accountability structures shape opportunities and expectations. | Fair procedure restrains favouritism; informal office routines may undermine written commitments. |
| Overlapping sites | A school teaches through its curriculum, peer relationships and the student’s interpretation. | Classify the mechanism, not merely the organisation: one setting can operate through all three lenses. |
A feedback system, not a one-way mould
Encounter
An institution or relationship presents an expectation.
Interpret
Experience and emotion affect what the person notices.
Evaluate
Ask whether the expectation respects equal dignity and public duty.
Act and reshape
Conduct becomes an example that can reinforce or challenge the surrounding norm.
Administrative vignette — who gets the outreach camp?
Competing signals
- A block officer remembers neglect in her own village; local acquaintances urge her to place the only camp there.
- Service data show a more remote settlement has substantially greater unmet need.
Ethical diagnosis
- Personal experience supplies sensitivity, not an automatic allocation entitlement.
- Community loyalty conflicts with impartial distribution; a transparent needs criterion is an institutional safeguard.
Reasoned response
- Use published deprivation and access criteria, explain the location and provide transport or a later visit for other villages.
- Record the evidence and monitor participation so procedure and real access are assessed together.
Distinctions that protect the answer
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Institutional influence means only punishment.
Recruitment, training, recognition, accessible procedures and role models also shape conduct.
A person shaped by prejudice cannot be held responsible.
Social explanation identifies causes; it does not remove agency or the duty to examine bias.
Prelims focus
- Inner, relational and structural influences are interconnected levels of analysis.
- Formal rules and informal organisational culture can send opposite messages.
Mains angle
- PYQ-style: Explain why ethical administration requires both character development and institutional reform.
- Structure an answer as influence → mechanism → risk → corrective, illustrated by one field decision.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which is the best use of the three-world framework?
Q2.A transparent appointment queue chiefly illustrates which influence?
Q3.Which inference is sound?
