Use this page as a retrieval drill: name the competing claims, identify the legal boundary, compare alternatives and state what remains regrettable. If the answer contains only virtue words, convert each into a concrete administrative act.
This is a synthesis map, not a replacement for the qualifications in individual topics. Statutory amendments and commencement questions require current verification.
Concept diagram
Five tools to carry into every dilemma
A portable toolkit gathers diagnosis, stakeholder mapping, comparison, justification and review into one revision image.
- First diagnose: a clear wrong is not a right-versus-right conflict.
- Leave a decision trail: facts, reasons, safeguards, outcomes and review.
Concept–distinction retrieval grid
| Retrieve | Do not confuse with | Decision cue |
|---|---|---|
| Concern versus dilemma | Every difficult situation being right versus right | Find a defensible moral claim on both sides. |
| Kidder’s four paradigms | Four compulsory stages | Truth–loyalty; individual–community; short–long term; justice–mercy. |
| Discretion | Permission to ignore binding rules | Identify lawful room for judgement and record relevant reasons. |
| Institutional loyalty | Personal obedience | Serve the lawful mandate, not concealment. |
| Actual / potential / apparent conflict | Three levels of proven corruption | Present overlap / foreseeable overlap / reasonable appearance of compromised judgement. |
| Residual ethical loss | Proof that the choice was necessarily wrong | Recognise and mitigate a justified claim left unmet. |
Four tests: retrieve both use and limit
- Publicity test: could the reasons withstand public scrutiny? Popular approval alone does not establish justice.
- Mirror test: can I honestly own this choice? Personal comfort can still reflect prejudice.
- Gandhi’s talisman: examine consequences for the poorest and weakest; translate concern into access and agency.
- Rawlsian veil: reason without knowing one’s social position; do not confuse fairness with a simple majority vote.
Instrument–safeguard quick recall
| Area | Anchor | Qualification |
|---|---|---|
| Official directions | Applicable conduct rules; written confirmation of oral instructions | A written instruction cannot legalise an unlawful act. |
| Transparency and privacy | RTI exemptions, public-interest balancing and applicable third-party procedure | Section 11 is a consultation procedure, not a blanket third-party veto; check current statutory text and amendment commencement. |
| Displacement and community rights | RFCTLARR 2013; FRA 2006; PESA 1996 | Apply the relevant enactment to its actual territorial and factual scope; do not assume identical consent rules everywhere. |
| Conflict of interest | Declaration, independent handling and recusal where appropriate | A declaration is not sufficient if the officer still shapes the decision; criminal liability under the PC Act requires statutory elements. |
| Whistle-blowing | PIDPI 2004; Whistle Blowers Protection Act 2014 | Distinguish CVC jurisdiction, reporting procedure and enactment from operational statutory protection. |
Original rapid drill: relocation of a vaccination camp
Diagnose in thirty seconds
- A health team proposes moving a camp from a remote hamlet to a central school because the school has refrigeration and better road access. Hamlets without transport would face a long journey. The clinical team says safe vaccine storage is non-negotiable.
- The live conflict is reliable, safe delivery versus equitable physical access. It is not solved by labelling staff uncaring or by waiving clinical safeguards.
Answer in four moves
- Confirm cold-chain and transport facts; map who would be excluded; compare the central camp with authorised outreach or scheduled transport; choose an option validated by the health team.
- Publish accessible timings, arrange approved support and monitor coverage in the remote hamlet, not only aggregate doses. Revisit the design if exclusion persists.
Memory aid
Last-minute answer audit
“CLEAR”
- CClaims: identify the genuine competing duties.
- LLimits: locate legal authority and non-negotiable safeguards.
- EEvaluate: compare feasible choices and distributional effects.
- AAct: name responsibility, sequence and protection measures.
- RReview: disclose residual cost, monitor and revise.
Common answer-writing traps
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
A middle path is always ethical.
Splitting the difference between truth and falsification does not resolve a dilemma.
Maximum total benefit settles every public decision.
Rights, fair distribution, uncertainty and vulnerability constrain aggregate calculations.
Recusal, disclosure and resignation are interchangeable.
They address different problems; specify who takes over and how service continuity is protected.
Calling something public interest proves it.
State the affected group, evidence, necessity and safeguards so the claim can be challenged.
Prelims focus
- Retrieve the four conflict paradigms and three conflict-of-interest categories.
- Distinguish triage criteria from social worth, and confidentiality from immunity.
Mains angle
- PYQ-style: explain why a justified administrative choice can still leave an ethical remainder.
- Practise a compact options table, then write a chosen course with one safeguard for each major risk.
- Conclude with measurable review, not a promise that no stakeholder will lose.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.The publicity test asks primarily whether:
Q2.Which best demonstrates revision becoming administrative judgement?
Q3.An apparent conflict of interest is best understood as:
