An officer considering an automated welfare-screening system can ask what fairness means, which principles should govern exclusion, and whether this particular system satisfies those principles. These are connected but distinguishable philosophical questions.
The dimensions are not compulsory chronological stages. Applied problems can expose weaknesses in a normative principle or ambiguity in a moral concept.
Real pictures
Faces of normative ethics
The three great normative approaches each have a classic voice: duty (Kant), consequences (Bentham and Mill) and character (Aristotle).
Immanuel Kant (1724–1804)
Kant founded duty-based (deontological) ethics: act only on a maxim you could will to become a universal law.
Image: Johann Gottlieb Becker (1720-1782) · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Jeremy Bentham (1748–1832)
Bentham’s utilitarianism judged actions by their consequences — the greatest happiness of the greatest number.
Image: Henry William Pickersgill · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
John Stuart Mill (1806–1873)
Mill refined utilitarianism, distinguishing higher and lower pleasures and defending individual liberty.
Image: London Stereoscopic Company · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Concept diagram
Three dimensions of ethical inquiry
A three-floor tower links meaning, standards and practical decisions.
- Meta-ethics examines meaning and foundations.
- Normative and applied ethics ask about standards and concrete problems.
Identify the kind of question
| Dimension | Core inquiry | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Meta-ethics | Meaning, truth, justification and knowledge of moral claims. | Is a claim of equal moral worth true independently of social approval? |
| Normative ethics | Which standards ought to guide action and character? | Should welfare decisions prioritise rights, aggregate welfare or special concern for the worst-off? |
| Applied ethics | What is justified in a specific domain given facts and constraints? | Should an unverified algorithm be allowed to suspend a household’s benefit? |
Three major normative lenses
Deontology: duties and constraints
- Rightness is not determined solely by the amount of good produced; duties and respect for persons matter.
- Kant’s approach asks whether a maxim can be universalised and rejects treating persons merely as means.
- Administrative strength: protects due process. Challenge: resolving competing duties without mechanical rigidity.
Consequentialism: evaluate outcomes
- Right action depends on consequences; theories differ over what counts as good and whether acts or rules are assessed.
- Utilitarianism is a consequentialist family centred on impartial aggregate welfare or utility, not simply the wishes of a numerical majority.
- Administrative strength: compares policy effects. Challenge: uncertainty, measurement and protecting individuals against harmful aggregation.
Virtue ethics: character and judgement
- Asks what a practically wise, just and honest person would perceive and do.
- Aristotle links ethical excellence with habituation and practical wisdom; virtue is not mere good intention.
- Administrative strength: ethical judgement beyond checklists. Challenge: translating character ideals into public reasons and accountable processes.
Objectivism and relativism concern moral status
Moral objectivism
- At least some moral truths do not depend on individual or cultural endorsement.
- Disagreement does not by itself show that no view is better justified.
- Objectivity does not require identical treatment regardless of relevant circumstances.
Moral relativism
- In a common formulation, moral truth or justification is relative to a cultural or other framework.
- The descriptive fact of cultural variation does not logically establish this philosophical claim.
- Relativism does not automatically entail tolerance; tolerance itself requires moral justification.
For Indian officials, cultural sensitivity operates within constitutional rights; custom cannot authorise untouchability or discriminatory denial of public services.
Trolley-type dilemma: what changes the judgement?
| Feature | Consequence-focused question | Duty-focused question | Virtue-focused question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Runaway trolley: divert from five people onto a track with one | Would diversion minimise deaths under the stated certainty? | Is the death foreseen as a side effect, or is a person being used as the means? | What would practical wisdom and responsibility require under genuine necessity? |
| Push a bystander to stop the trolley | Do equal casualty totals exhaust the relevant effects, including precedent and security? | Does intentionally using a person as an instrument violate a constraint? | How do justice, compassion and respect shape the response? |
Philosophers disagree; not all deontologists reject diversion and not all consequentialists ignore rules. Real administrative cases rarely have perfect certainty or only two possible actions.
Vignette: an algorithm flags pension fraud
A municipal pension system flags many elderly recipients after an address-format change. A vendor recommends immediate suspension to maximise projected savings.
Clarify concepts and facts
Distinguish suspicion from fraud and savings from legitimate deprivation. Test error rates, especially for recipients needing assisted access.
Compare reasons
Duty supports notice and fair hearing; consequences include hunger and recovery of wrongful payments; virtues call for honesty about uncertainty and compassion without favouritism.
Justify an actionable decision
Do not treat a flag as conclusive. Follow governing law, arrange human verification and accessible appeals, and use lawful interim safeguards against wrongful exclusion.
Philosophy errors that weaken GS4 answers
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Meta-ethics means an especially high standard of personal morality.
It studies moral language, knowledge and status; it is not a ranking of people’s goodness.
Utilitarianism means whatever pleases the majority.
It gives each affected person’s welfare impartial consideration; majority preferences can impose severe harms on a minority.
Deontology means obeying every existing law.
Moral duties and legal commands are not identical; a duty-based argument can criticise an unjust law.
Virtue ethics makes evidence unnecessary.
Practical wisdom needs informed judgement about circumstances, consequences and appropriate action.
Prelims focus
- Classify meaning/status questions as meta-ethical, standards as normative and concrete domain decisions as applied.
- Utilitarianism is a form of consequentialism; objectivism is not synonymous with deontology.
Mains angle
- PYQ-style: Compare duty, welfare and character as guides to public decision-making, using one common case.
- Do not merely name three theories. Explain their competing reasons, acknowledge constraints and defend a workable course with safeguards.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.‘Can moral claims be true independently of social approval?’ is primarily a question of:
Q2.Which statement correctly describes utilitarianism?
Q3.An officer says that truthful conduct is needed even when concealment would produce a convenient result. The argument primarily invokes:
