Article 320 — matters for consultation
Recruitment
- Conduct examinations for appointments
- Methods of recruitment to civil services and posts
- Principles for appointment, promotion and transfer
Service matters
- Disciplinary matters affecting a civil servant
- Claims for legal costs in defending official acts
- Claims for injury pension
Consulted vs not consulted
Must be consulted
- Recruitment rules and methods
- Promotions and disciplinary action
- Matters the President / Governor refers
Outside consultation
- Reservation of posts for backward classes (Art 16(4))
- Claims of SCs and STs under Art 335
- Posts excluded by presidential or gubernatorial regulation
Exclusion regulations must be laid before the legislature, which can amend or repeal them.
Accountability loop
Advice tendered
The Commission gives its recommendation.
Government decides
Advice is not binding; consultation is directory, not mandatory (Manbodhan Lal Srivastava, 1957).
Annual report
Art 323: report to the President / Governor, laid before the legislature with reasons for non-acceptance.
Wider picture
- Art 321: Parliament or a State Legislature may give extra functions
- UPSC is the central recruiting agency; DoPT is the central personnel agency
- Art 315(4): UPSC may serve a State's needs on the Governor's request with the President's approval
Prelims traps
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Government must follow UPSC advice.
It may differ, but must explain non-acceptance in the report laid before Parliament.
The UPSC is consulted on reservation policy.
Art 320(4) excludes reservation matters under Art 16(4) and Art 335.
Prelims focus
- Art 320 exclusions
- Art 323 reports
Mains angle
- Critically evaluate the advisory character of Public Service Commissions in protecting merit.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.UPSC is NOT consulted on:
Q2.The Supreme Court held consultation under Article 320 to be:
Q3.Additional functions may be conferred on the UPSC by:
