Company courts, Crown courts and statutory codes gradually formed an integrated legal hierarchy. Legal uniformity and appellate institutions expanded alongside racial privilege, costly procedure and coercive legislation.
Distinguish the Supreme Court of colonial Calcutta from both the later High Court and independent India’s Supreme Court.
Concept diagram
An appellate courtroom: codes and inequality
Original interpretive scene; human figures are symbolic, not portraits. Calcutta, Bombay and Madras High Courts began functioning in 1862.
- Calcutta, Bombay and Madras High Courts began functioning in 1862.
- Codification expanded uniform law; racial privilege remained contested.
Map · India
The first three High Courts, 1862
- 1. Calcutta [Kolkata] — High Court established in 1862
- 2. Bombay [Mumbai] — High Court established in 1862
- 3. Madras [Chennai] — High Court established in 1862
The High Courts replaced the earlier Supreme Courts and Sadar courts in the presidency towns.
- The enabling Indian High Courts Act was passed in 1861.
- Allahabad High Court followed in 1866, not 1862.
Institutional anatomy: judiciary and rule of law
| Provision or institution | Precise content | Consequence or limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Hastings, 1772 | District diwani adalats handled civil matters; faujdari arrangements addressed criminal justice, with higher courts in the provincial capital. | Company revenue power generated a parallel claim to administer justice. |
| Cornwallis, 1793 | The Cornwallis Code reorganised courts and separated judicial from revenue functions in important district arrangements. | Judicial offices remained racially restricted; later administrations altered this separation. |
| Codification | The first Law Commission began in 1834; the Indian Penal Code was enacted in 1860 and took effect in 1862. | Common criminal legislation did not eliminate plural personal laws. |
| High Courts | The Indian High Courts Act, 1861 enabled High Courts at Calcutta, Bombay and Madras, established in 1862, replacing the older Supreme and Sadar courts there. | Two competing judicial traditions were brought under single presidency-level institutions. |
| Federal adjudication | The Federal Court opened in 1937 under the 1935 Act; Privy Council appeals continued. | The Federal Court was neither the 1774 Supreme Court nor the final court of independent republican India. |
Milestones for judiciary and rule of law
1772–74
Company adalats and a Crown Supreme Court emerge through different legal routes
Company adalats and a Crown Supreme Court emerge through different legal routes.
1860–62
Penal codification and the presidency High Courts reshape the judicial system
Penal codification and the presidency High Courts reshape the judicial system.
1937
The Federal Court begins constitutional adjudication under the late-colonial scheme
The Federal Court begins constitutional adjudication under the late-colonial scheme.
Two analytical lenses
Mechanism of change
- District diwani adalats handled civil matters; faujdari arrangements addressed criminal justice, with higher courts in the provincial capital.
- Judicial offices remained racially restricted; later administrations altered this separation.
Limits of the settlement
- The Federal Court was neither the 1774 Supreme Court nor the final court of independent republican India.
- Distinguish the Supreme Court of colonial Calcutta from both the later High Court and independent India’s Supreme Court.
Avoid these judiciary and rule of law confusions
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
The Indian Penal Code came into force in 1860.
It was enacted in 1860 but commenced in 1862.
Rule of law meant equal treatment regardless of race in colonial India.
European privileges and the Ilbert Bill controversy of 1883 exposed limits to legal equality.
Prelims focus
- Which jurisdiction did diwani courts primarily exercise?
- What did the presidency High Courts replace?
Mains angle
- Balance codification and institutional integration against racial discrimination and unequal access to remedies.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.The first presidency High Courts were established in which year?
Q2.Which pair is correct?
Q3.Which body remained an imperial appellate authority?
