A resident may approve of waste segregation but live where separate collection is unavailable. An employee may support whistleblowing yet fear retaliation and doubt that a reporting channel works. Treating non-performance as proof of hypocrisy ignores the steps between approving an action and being able to carry it out.
Prediction improves when attitude and behaviour are specified at comparable levels of action, target, context and time. A general commitment to environmental protection is not identical to an intention to segregate waste tomorrow morning.
Concept diagram
A favourable attitude still needs a workable bridge
Ajzen: attitude, subjective norm and perceived control shape intention. Actual constraints can block behaviour even when intention is strong.
- Ajzen: attitude, subjective norm and perceived control shape intention.
- Actual constraints can block behaviour even when intention is strong.
LaPiere’s 1934 study: a caution, not a universal law
| Aspect | What to retain | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Field encounter | LaPiere travelled with a Chinese couple; the overwhelming majority of establishments visited served them. | Observed reception occurred in particular interpersonal situations. |
| Later enquiry | Many responding establishments subsequently expressed refusal to accept Chinese guests in a written enquiry. | Responses were not obtained from all establishments, and respondents may not have been the same individuals who served the party. |
| Inference | Reported evaluations and situated behaviour can diverge. | The design does not establish that attitudes never predict behaviour or supply a precise causal explanation of every discrepancy. |
Ajzen’s Theory of Planned Behaviour (1991)
Attitude towards the behaviour
Is performing this specific act evaluated favourably? Expected outcomes and their evaluation matter.
Subjective norm
Do people important to me appear to expect or approve the act? Perceived social expectations affect intention.
Perceived behavioural control
Do I believe I have the resources, capacity and opportunity? This can affect intention and, where realistic, behaviour.
Intention and enactment
Intention is a proximal predictor, not a guarantee. Actual control, unexpected events and competing habits still affect execution.
Diagnose the broken link
| Observation | Possible explanation | Appropriate response |
|---|---|---|
| Approves but does not intend | The act is too vague, or perceived social expectations oppose it. | Specify the action and investigate relevant expectations. |
| Intends but cannot act | Facilities, time, authority or transport are missing. | Remove the practical barrier and verify that access is real. |
| Reports high control but fails | Self-assessment is inaccurate or conditions change. | Observe the task, test resources and revise implementation. |
| Acts only when watched | External compliance has not become a durable commitment. | Review incentives and seek private, voluntary feedback rather than assume internalisation. |
Original vignette: segregation without collection
A misleading diagnosis
- A municipal survey records support for household waste segregation, but mixed waste still reaches the transfer point. Officials propose blaming residents in public messages.
- Field observation finds some homes segregate but collection staff combine the streams because the vehicle has no practical separation arrangement.
Repair the opportunity structure
- The commissioner tests a feasible separate-collection arrangement, coordinates downstream processing and gives households clear collection information. Monitoring follows the whole chain rather than only doorstep compliance.
- Reassess intentions and conduct after facilities work. Fair persuasion cannot demand an action that the service system routinely defeats.
Distinctions worth protecting
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Subjective norm means the legally prescribed rule.
It means perceived social pressure from relevant others; legal rules may influence it but are not the same construct.
Perceived control is identical to actual control.
Confidence can be mistaken. Real resources and constraints must be checked independently.
Prelims focus
- TPB: attitude towards the act + subjective norm + perceived control → intention; control also matters for enactment.
- LaPiere illustrates a discrepancy with methodological limits, not the irrelevance of attitudes.
Mains angle
- PYQ-style: Why do awareness campaigns sometimes fail to change public behaviour? Distinguish evaluative, normative and practical barriers.
- Use behaviour-specific measures and field observation before labelling citizens inconsistent.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which is not a core determinant of intention in TPB?
Q2.Citizens intend to use a complaint portal, but it is inaccessible to screen readers. The first response should be:
Q3.LaPiere’s study most cautiously supports which conclusion?
