New UPSC Foundation, Optional and TGPSC/APPSC batches are open — book your counselling slot.Explore coursesGroup 2 crash course ₹9,999Today's Current AffairsToday's Daily QuizPlaces in NewsCall 98804 87071

Ethics & Integrity · Chapter 6 · Topic 15 of 15

Attitude and Influence: Quick Revision

Components, theories, experiments and traps

Revision

In an answer or field diagnosis, connect the inner evaluation to the social setting and the observable choice. A citizen’s refusal may express disagreement, distrust, fear of neighbours or inability to act; the remedy depends on which explanation fits the evidence.

Revision rule: identify the mechanism, state its limit, choose a lawful intervention and name a measure that could show it failed.

Concept diagram

Diagnose the mechanism before choosing the tool

Separate ABC, planned behaviour, dissonance and persuasion routes. Name the mechanism, identify constraints, then propose an ethical response.

  • Separate ABC, planned behaviour, dissonance and persuasion routes.
  • Name the mechanism, identify constraints, then propose an ethical response.

Core vocabulary: one distinction per line

ConceptRetrieveAdministrative implication
Attitude and ABCEvaluation involving affect, cognition and behavioural tendencyStated intention is not identical to completed action.
Content, structure, functionWhat is evaluated; component relationships; psychological purposeA factual correction may not shift an identity-protecting attitude.
Strength and ambivalenceAccessibility and commitment differ from mixed positive and negative evaluationsStrong attitudes can resist change; mixed feelings do not imply ignorance.
Explicit and implicitReported evaluations differ from automatic associationsDo not treat a questionnaire or IAT as a complete individual diagnosis.
FormationConditioning, observation and repeated exposure can shape evaluationRepeated exposure may increase familiarity, but does not guarantee approval.
Attitude–behaviour gapContext and control intervene between evaluation and actionCheck access and constraints before blaming motivation.
DissonanceDiscomfort from relevant inconsistencyPeople may change conduct, revise belief or rationalise; improvement is not automatic.

Thinker and model retrieval

AnchorCore contributionBoundary to remember
AllportAttitude as a readiness shaped through experienceA disposition influences responses without mechanically determining every act.
Katz (1960)Utilitarian/adjustive, knowledge, ego-defensive and value-expressive functionsDifferent functions call for different change strategies.
LaPiere (1934)Observed service encounters and later questionnaire replies divergedRespondents were not necessarily the same individuals; avoid a simple universal prediction.
Ajzen (1991)Attitude toward behaviour, subjective norm and perceived behavioural control shape intention; control also matters for actionIntentions need actual opportunities and resources.
BemSelf-perception: people may infer attitudes from their behaviour, especially with weak or ambiguous prior attitudesNot all attitude change requires inner discomfort.
Festinger (1957)Cognitive dissonance and motivation to reduce inconsistencyRationalisation is one possible reduction, not proof of ethical learning.
Asch; Milgram; JanisConformity; obedience; groupthinkSituational influence is not a defence for wrongdoing.
Hovland–Yale; Petty and CacioppoCommunication variables; central/peripheral elaboration routesCredibility, processing and context matter; there is no universally winning slogan.
Allport’s contact hypothesisConstructive contact favoured by equal status, cooperation, common goals and institutional supportToken exposure is not sufficient.
Thaler and Sunstein (2008)Choice architecture and nudgesEffectiveness does not settle agency, equity or transparency.

A compact case-answer route

  1. Locate the evaluation

    Specify the attitude object, beliefs, feelings and intended response; do not label an entire community resistant.

  2. Diagnose the gap

    Check personal evaluation, perceived norms, practical control and past institutional experience.

  3. Select and justify means

    Match evidence, dialogue, service repair or norm support to the barrier; protect informed choice and rights.

  4. Observe and revise

    Specify sustained action and unequal effects; revise the diagnosis if the expected change does not occur.

Integrated drill: the unused drinking-water point

Situation and ethical issue

  • A new community water point works reliably, yet some households avoid it. Officials interpret this as ignorance and propose public pledges. Interviews reveal a prior contamination scare and intimidation by users claiming priority on caste grounds.
  • The ABC diagnosis includes a safety belief, anxiety and avoidance. Actual exclusion and perceived social sanctions also reduce control; publicity alone cannot solve the problem.

Reasoned administrative response

  • Verify water quality, explain results and uncertainty accessibly, maintain transparent testing and respond to the earlier failure. Protect equal access, investigate intimidation and use applicable lawful remedies.
  • Facilitate safe cooperative oversight with genuine representation, without making vulnerable families negotiate away their rights. Track repeat use, waiting times, water quality and confidential reports of harassment; reject coerced pledges and misleading success claims.

Rapid sorting: what kind of influence is this?

Agency and reasoning

  • Persuasion offers assessable reasons; constructive contact can challenge prejudice.
  • A transparent, easy-to-decline nudge may make an already valued action simpler.

Pressure and distorted judgement

  • Conformity seeks alignment; compliance follows a request; obedience follows perceived authority.
  • Manipulation exploits or conceals; groupthink suppresses scrutiny; coercion constrains choice.
VS

Classify the mechanism before evaluating it: not every influence is harmful, and not every beneficial outcome validates its means.

Memory aid

Final review: CLEAR

“Clarify, Listen, Enable, Audit, Reassess.”

  • CClarify the attitude object and distinguish belief from evidence.
  • LListen for trust, emotion, social norms and excluded voices.
  • EEnable feasible action without deception or improper pressure.
  • AAudit autonomy, fairness, privacy and actual service outcomes.
  • RReassess sustained behaviour and unintended effects.

Distinctions that prevent weak answers

Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.

  • Behavioural tendency in ABC means the person has already acted.

    It includes readiness or intention; actual conduct also depends on context and control.

  • Self-perception and dissonance are the same explanation.

    The former involves inferring attitudes from behaviour; the latter centres on discomfort and consistency restoration.

  • Non-partisanship requires value neutrality.

    Civil servants should be non-partisan while actively committed to constitutional equality and dignity.

  • A successful campaign proves changed beliefs.

    Observed action may reflect incentives, constraints or public compliance; test mechanisms and persistence separately.

Prelims focus

  • Recall Katz’s four functions, TPB’s three intention predictors and the two influence motives.
  • Retrieve stereotype–prejudice–discrimination; descriptive–injunctive norm; persuasion–nudge–coercion–manipulation.

Mains angle

  • PYQ-style: Explain why a favourable attitude may not produce ethical behaviour. Use a model, a counterexample and institutional safeguards.
  • PYQ-style: Design a social-attitude intervention that is effective and respects autonomy. Include barrier diagnosis, infrastructure, ethical boundaries and evaluation.
  • For case studies, avoid a list of theorists: identify the operative mechanism and defend a specific course of action.

Flip & recall

Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.

Practice MCQs

Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.

0 / 3 correct · 3 left

  1. Q1.A household supports safe water but is threatened at the source. The best initial diagnosis is:

  2. Q2.Which correctly distinguishes two models?

  3. Q3.Which is the strongest closing line in a campaign case answer?

Free UPSC daily current affairs quiz — 10 questions, new every day at 8 am IST.

Call nowWhatsApp