Use this sheet to check an answer already drafted: can a reader trace the chosen action back to the evidence, the people at risk and the public duty?
Chapter 9 teaches the full dilemma framework, case-study answer method and worked case. This is a retrieval-and-error-checking sheet, not a substitute for that teaching; follow the question’s specific subparts.
Concept diagram
Climb from facts to follow-through
Build the answer through facts, people, conflicts, options, a decision and delivery.
- Separate verified facts from assumptions.
- Finish with responsibility, records and review.
Seven checkpoints: the revision spine
Facts
Separate established facts, allegations and missing information; identify urgency and your actual authority.
Stakeholders
Identify direct and indirect burdens, including people without an organised voice.
Values / laws
Name the precise conflict; distinguish binding limits from lawful discretion.
Options
Include inaction and a feasible safeguarded alternative; reject fabricated powers.
Consequences
Compare immediate harm, distribution, reversibility and institutional precedent.
Choice
State what you will do within your role, who implements it and when it is reviewed.
Justification
Explain why the strongest rival option loses; acknowledge and mitigate the residual cost.
Stakeholder map: power × interest, with an impact overlay
| Feature | Interest / power | Direct or indirect effect | Engagement response |
|---|---|---|---|
| High power, high interest | Manage closely | An implementing agency may directly control continuity | Seek an accountable decision and assign responsibilities |
| High power, low interest | Keep engaged | A funding authority may be indirectly affected through budgets | Flag legal duties and the cost of delayed support |
| Low power, high interest | Prioritise voice and protection | Dependent service users may suffer direct, irreversible harm | Accessible consultation, representation and grievance route |
| Low power, low expressed interest | Check for hidden exposure | Future users or dispersed taxpayers may face indirect burdens | Outreach and monitoring; silence may reflect exclusion |
Power guides engagement, not moral worth. Mark direct/indirect exposure separately for each actor: neither impact nor vulnerability can be inferred from the quadrant alone.
Options matrix: a faulty medicine-storage refrigerator
| Option | Pros | Cons / ethical risk | Feasibility / safeguard |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scenario | A clinic manager receives a temperature alert; medicine potency is uncertain | Patients need treatment today; replacement stock is limited | Verify logs and obtain qualified pharmacy advice without delaying protection |
| Continue routine dispensing | Avoids an immediate queue | Potential patient harm; conceals uncertainty | Reject pending safety assessment of affected stock |
| Close the whole clinic indefinitely | Simple containment | Denies unrelated care and leaves patients without alternatives | Overbroad where unaffected services can safely continue |
| Isolate affected stock; arrange safe supply and referrals | Protects safety while preserving essential care | Transport, delay and replacement costs remain | Preferred: record batches, coordinate authorised transfer, notify relevant authority and review restoration |
Four tests: different questions, not four verdicts
Publicity
- Could I explain the reasons to informed public scrutiny?
- Publish the rule and reasons where lawful; do not expose patient identities to prove transparency.
Mirror
- Could I respect myself after knowingly taking this decision?
- Useful for self-deception, but a comfortable conscience may still carry prejudice.
Gandhi’s talisman
- Consider what the decision does to the poorest and weakest person affected, including their agency.
- Ask whether a referral is actually reachable by a patient who cannot pay for travel.
Veil of ignorance
- Would the allocation rule be acceptable without knowing my own place among those affected?
- A Rawls-inspired fairness check on the rule, not a prediction of everyone’s preferences.
Eliminate first; compare second
Non-negotiable constraints
- Do not falsify a safety record or trade away equal protection for convenience.
- An impressive welfare total cannot alone authorise an unlawful act.
Reasoned trade-offs
- Among lawful options, assess severity, likelihood, distribution and reversibility of harm.
- Explain why a narrower restriction protects patients better than a blanket closure.
The four tests reveal tensions; they neither override law nor mechanically select the answer.
Last-minute answer audit
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Unstated facts can be added to make my solution work.
State necessary assumptions explicitly and describe how they will be verified; do not invent funds, powers or guilt.
A stakeholder list is enough.
Show who bears which cost and how the decision protects or hears them.
Inform the superior is the complete decision.
Specify immediate protective action within competence, lawful escalation and a review point.
Every option deserves equal space.
Briefly reject clearly impermissible options; spend analysis on the genuine contest between feasible alternatives.
Prelims focus
- Power is capacity to influence; interest is the stake in an outcome; neither determines entitlement.
- Publicity tests defensibility, not popularity; the mirror test is not objective proof.
Mains angle
- Use Chapter 9 for the full writing method; use this page to find a missing link in your reasoning.
- Finish the audit with one line each on authority, implementation, residual harm and review; avoid repeating the entire framework under every subquestion.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.A group has little influence but depends entirely on a threatened service. What follows?
Q2.Which is the most accurate use of the publicity test?
Q3.Which comparison best completes an options matrix?
