Four lenses ask different questions: can the principle be universalised, what welfare follows, what practical wisdom requires, and whether institutions are fair to free and equal persons?
Chapter 4 teaches these theories in depth; Chapter 9 shows how competing reasons enter a defensible decision. Use the comparison as a diagnostic aid, not a claim that all four theories are interchangeable.
Real pictures
Four lenses to quote
Duty, utility, virtue and fairness — the four Western lenses most used in GS4.
Immanuel Kant (1724–1804)
Categorical imperative: act only on maxims you could will as universal law; treat humanity always as an end.
Image: Johann Gottlieb Becker (1720-1782) · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
John Stuart Mill (1806–1873)
Utilitarianism with higher and lower pleasures; the harm principle in On Liberty.
Image: London Stereoscopic Company · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Aristotle (384–322 BCE)
Virtue as a golden mean formed by habit and guided by practical wisdom.
Image: After Lysippos · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
John Rawls (1921–2002)
Justice as fairness chosen behind a veil of ignorance; the difference principle.
Image: Published by the Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. Photograph taken by Alec Rawls · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Concept diagram
Four instruments for testing a decision
Kant, Mill, Aristotle and Rawls illuminate different questions about justified action.
- Distinguish universal duty from aggregate welfare.
- Add practical wisdom and fair institutional arrangements.
Four-lens examination grid
| Feature | Core test | Administrative strength | Risk in careless use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kant | Universal law; persons as ends, never merely means | Explains principled refusal of fraud or coercion | Reducing duty to obedience to whatever a superior orders |
| Mill | Impartial utility, including quality of well-being | Makes diffuse and long-term welfare visible | Calling a majority’s preference the same thing as aggregate welfare |
| Aristotle | Practical wisdom guided by cultivated virtue | Connects judgement, context and stable character | Mistaking the mean for splitting the difference |
| Rawls | Fair terms of cooperation; basic liberties and distributive justice | Tests institutions from an impartial starting point | Ignoring liberty and fair opportunity while citing the least advantaged |
Kant and Mill: disagreement worth explaining
Kantian route
- A good will and acting from duty ground moral worth; legality alone does not establish a moral motive.
- Test the maxim, not merely whether a desired outcome can be obtained.
- Respect for humanity forbids treating a person merely as an instrument.
Millian route
- Give each person’s welfare impartial consideration; consequences extend beyond the immediate beneficiary.
- Mill distinguishes higher and lower pleasures; utility is not just money or a headcount.
- On Liberty defends liberty through the harm principle; social dislike alone does not justify coercion.
Neither is a recipe for arbitrary administration: public action remains constrained by constitutional rights, lawful authority and evidence.
Rawls: preserve the order of the argument
| Element | Revision meaning | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Original position | A hypothetical fair choice situation | Calling it an actual historical contract |
| Veil of ignorance | Parties lack knowledge of their particular social position and natural endowments | Imagining complete ignorance of general facts about society |
| Equal basic liberties | An adequate scheme of equal basic liberties has priority | Trading a minority’s basic liberty for extra revenue |
| Fair equality of opportunity | Positions must be genuinely accessible under fair conditions | Treating formal permission alone as fair opportunity |
| Difference principle | Social and economic inequalities must work to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged | Claiming every benefit must be numerically identical |
Aristotle’s mean: proportion, not mediocrity
Locate the relevant extremes
- Courage lies between cowardice and rashness; what is courageous depends on the danger and the agent’s responsibilities.
- The mean is relative to us and determined by reason, not an average of two proposed policies.
Practise sound judgement
- Phronesis helps an officer recognise which details matter and select fitting means to good ends.
- Some actions are wrong in kind: there is no virtuous middle amount of deliberate fraud.
Original application: unsafe testing shortcut
Facts
A water-board engineer is pressed to certify an untested treatment unit so that a public event can proceed.
Compare reasons
Kant rejects a false assurance; Mill includes contamination risks and lost trust; Aristotle asks for informed courage; Rawls highlights residents unable to buy alternatives.
Decision
Decline false certification, arrange accredited testing and safe interim supply, record reasons and escalate the service risk to the competent authority.
Precision under time pressure
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
The veil of ignorance is simply empathy.
It is a device for selecting fair principles of the basic structure; empathy can assist understanding but is not the device itself.
Utilitarian reasoning permits ignoring the welfare of unpopular people.
Their interests count impartially too; aggregation’s possible conflicts with rights require explicit discussion.
Golden mean means approving a smaller bribe.
Virtue does not mean moderation in wrongdoing; reject the bribe and identify a lawful path.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which proposal best illustrates a misuse of Aristotle?
Q2.Which is consistent with Rawls’s framework?
Q3.Mill’s qualitative distinction concerns:
