Four interpretive doctrines
Pith and substance
- Look at the true nature of a law, not incidental effects
- A valid State law survives incidental trespass on a Union subject (State of Bombay v F.N. Balsara, 1951)
Colourable legislation
- What cannot be done directly cannot be done indirectly
- Tests competence, not motive (K.C. Gajapati Narayan Deo, 1953)
Territorial nexus
- A State law may reach outside persons or things with a sufficient connection to the State
Harmonious construction
- Read entries to give effect to both, avoiding conflict where possible
Article 254 — conflict on a Concurrent subject
Rule — Art 254(1)
If a State law is repugnant to a Union law on a Concurrent subject, the Union law prevails to the extent of repugnancy.
Exception — Art 254(2)
A State law reserved for and assented to by the President prevails in that State.
Override
Parliament can still later add to, amend or repeal that State law.
Related supremacy rules
- Art 246: Union List prevails over the State List where entries overlap
- Art 251: a State law inconsistent with a law made under Art 249 or 250 is inoperative while the Union law lasts
- Repugnancy under Art 254 applies only to the Concurrent List
Prelims traps
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
A repugnant State law is void for all time.
It is inoperative to the extent of repugnancy; with presidential assent it may prevail in that State.
The President's assent under Art 254(2) protects a State law from later Union amendment.
Parliament can still amend or repeal it (proviso to Art 254(2)).
Colourable legislation examines the legislature's motive.
It examines competence; motive is irrelevant.
Prelims focus
- Doctrine–case matching
- Art 254(1) vs 254(2)
Mains angle
- Explain how the doctrine of pith and substance has helped preserve the federal balance.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.A State law on a Concurrent subject prevails over a Union law in that State if:
Q2.The doctrine of pith and substance was applied in:
Q3.Article 251 deals with inconsistency between State laws and Union laws made under:
