New UPSC Foundation, Optional and TGPSC/APPSC batches are open — book your counselling slot.Explore coursesGroup 2 crash course ₹9,999Today's Current AffairsToday's Daily QuizPlaces in NewsCall 98804 87071

Economic Survey 2026 · Chapter 15 · Topic 3 of 14

The Urban Governance Deficit

Fragmented functions across ULBs and parastatals

Governance

Quick answer

Economic Survey 2025-26 finds fragmented city authority undermines growth: India’s top ten cities hold about 9% of its population but generate nearly 28% of GDP.

The urban governance deficit is the mismatch between responsibility for city outcomes and control over the powers, people and resources needed to deliver them. Economic Survey 2025-26 locates the problem in fragmented authority across urban local bodies, development authorities, state departments and parastatal agencies.

Concept diagram

One city, many decision-makers

Fragmented responsibilities blur accountability for everyday urban services. Conceptual illustration; objects and dimensions do not encode measured values.

  • ULBs, state departments and parastatals may control different functions.
  • Align functions, funds and functionaries with clear responsibility.

Basics: constitutional recognition is not complete economic agency

74th Constitutional Amendment

  • The Constitution (74th Amendment) Act, 1992 inserted Part IXA on municipalities and the Twelfth Schedule, which lists 18 municipal functions. It came into force in 1993.
  • Article 243W enables state legislatures to endow municipalities with powers and responsibilities. Listing a function is not proof that operational staff, assets and revenue powers have actually been transferred.

Municipal forms and planning

  • Nagar Panchayats serve transitional areas, Municipal Councils smaller urban areas and Municipal Corporations larger urban areas, subject to constitutional provisions and state law.
  • Article 243ZE provides for metropolitan planning committees to prepare draft development plans. Metropolitan coordination is wider than management of a single municipal boundary.

Three dimensions of devolution

  • Functions specify what the city must do; functionaries provide staff and operational control; funds supply spending capacity. Transferring only one dimension leaves accountability incomplete.
  • Policing is not one of the 18 Twelfth Schedule functions. Urban governance involves state powers beyond the municipal functional list.

Who holds the levers? The Survey’s fragmented institutional map

InstitutionRole or power highlightedCoordination problem
Urban Local BodiesLocal representation and municipal servicesCitizens may blame elected municipal leaders for decisions outside their control.
Development authoritiesDevelopment and land-related planning powersLand-use choices may not align with municipal services or housing needs.
State line departmentsKey powers including cadre management and policingLocal priorities compete with state-level administrative control.
Parastatal agenciesSpecialised utilities and infrastructure deliverySector-specific projects can lack integrated citywide accountability.

Data chart

Economic concentration: top ten Indian cities, 2023 comparison

0102030Per centPopulation shareGDP shareShare, Population share: 99Share, GDP share: 2828
  • The Survey describes the GDP-share/population-share ratio as about 3×.
  • An infrastructure failure in these concentrated economic centres can have effects beyond their municipal boundaries.

Source: Economic Survey 2025-26, paragraph 15.18 (comparison cited from Neuralcity.in, 2023) · Approximate shares as reported by the Survey; the comparison is not a municipal fiscal statistic.

Show the data (Per cent)
Period / itemShare
Population share9
GDP share28

Concentration ratios in the comparison cited by the Survey

CountryTop-city GDP-share/population-share ratio
IndiaAbout 3×
ChinaAbout 1.8×
United StatesAbout 1.5×
GermanyAbout 1.5×

Why infrastructure alone can disappoint

Transport cannot repair every planning failure

  • A metro can improve movement while failing to maximise productivity if housing supply, land use and job locations remain misaligned. The Survey warns against capital-intensive assets without coordinated institutional reform.

An accountability gap, not simply a spending gap

  • When budgets, land-use authority and service delivery sit in different institutions, citizens cannot easily identify who should correct poor outcomes.
  • Mayoral selection and powers vary across Indian states; the Survey’s global-city comparison should not be read as a claim that all Indian mayors are directly elected or possess uniform executive powers.

Way forward: connect the electoral mandate to executable powers

  1. Assign responsibility

    Publish a clear allocation of functions and decision rights across the municipality and other agencies.

  2. Coordinate metropolitan strategy

    Align land use, transport, housing and economic development around a common regional plan.

  3. Provide fiscal and staffing capacity

    Match responsibilities with empowered personnel, own revenues and predictable transfers.

  4. Make outcomes reviewable

    Assess access to jobs and service reliability, with visible institutional ownership and corrective action.

Exam traps: keep the distinctions intact

Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.

  • The 74th Amendment automatically transferred all 18 functions in every state.

    Operational devolution depends on state law and actual transfer of authority, staff and resources.

  • A city’s GDP contribution is the municipality’s revenue.

    Economic output generated in an urban area is distinct from taxes and fees collected by its government.

  • Direct election alone guarantees an empowered mayor.

    Electoral legitimacy must be matched with executive, planning, staffing and financial powers.

Prelims focus

  • Part IXA and the Twelfth Schedule arise from the 74th Amendment; the Schedule lists 18 functions.
  • Distinguish Article 243W on municipal powers from Article 243ZE on metropolitan planning.
  • Learn the four actors: ULBs, development authorities, state departments and parastatals.

Mains angle

  • “Infrastructure without institutional reform delivers suboptimal economic returns.” Discuss with land–housing–transport linkages.
  • Analyse urban decentralisation through functions, functionaries and funds; propose measurable accountability without assuming every function must be municipalised.

Flip & recall

Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.

Practice MCQs

Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.

0 / 3 correct · 3 left

  1. Q1.Which amendment inserted Part IXA and the Twelfth Schedule?

  2. Q2.Which combination best represents effective urban devolution?

  3. Q3.Which is NOT listed as a municipal function in the Twelfth Schedule?

Free UPSC daily current affairs quiz — 10 questions, new every day at 8 am IST.

Call nowWhatsApp