Three emergencies compared
| Feature | National (352) | President's Rule (356) | Financial (360) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grounds | War, external aggression or armed rebellion | Failure of constitutional machinery in a State (also Art 365) | Threat to financial stability or credit of India |
| Approval | Both Houses within 1 month, by special majority | Both Houses within 2 months, by simple majority | Both Houses within 2 months, by simple majority |
| Duration | Six months at a time; renewed by special majority; no maximum | Six months at a time, up to 3 years; beyond 1 year only with conditions | Indefinite once approved, until revoked |
| Revocation | President; or Lok Sabha disapproval by simple majority | President, any time | President, any time |
| Effect | Union may direct States; Parliament legislates on State List | State executive taken over; Assembly suspended or dissolved | Union financial directions; salaries including judges' may be cut |
| Used | 1962, 1971, 1975 | Over 125 times | Never |
Article 358 vs Article 359
Article 358
Automatic
- Article 19 suspended automatically
- Only for war or external aggression, not armed rebellion
- Whole of India or the affected area
Article 359
By Presidential order
- Suspends the right to move courts for rights named in the order
- Articles 20 and 21 can never be named
- Can be limited by area and time
358 suspends a right; 359 suspends its enforcement.
44th Amendment safeguards (1978)
- Proclamation only on the Union Cabinet's written advice
- 'Armed rebellion' replaced 'internal disturbance'
- Parliamentary approval within one month (earlier two)
- Special majority for approval and every six-monthly renewal
- One-tenth of Lok Sabha members can requisition a special sitting to disapprove
- Articles 20 and 21 placed beyond suspension
Prelims traps
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Special majority is needed only to continue a National Emergency.
It is needed for the first approval within one month and for every renewal.
A National Emergency must cover the whole country.
Since the 42nd Amendment it may be limited to a part of India.
President's Rule can be imposed only on the Governor's report.
The President may act 'otherwise' as well, but proclamation is subject to judicial review (S.R. Bommai, 1994).
Prelims focus
- Approval timelines and majorities
- 358 vs 359
- Financial Emergency effects
Mains angle
- How did S.R. Bommai (1994) and the 44th Amendment together restrain the misuse of emergency powers?
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Article 19 is suspended automatically under Article 358 when a National Emergency is declared on the ground of:
Q2.President's Rule beyond one year requires:
Q3.Which emergency, once approved, continues indefinitely?
