The Constitution says the President appoints judges after 'consultation' with the Chief Justice and other judges. The word 'collegium' does not appear anywhere in the text — the system was created by the Supreme Court's own interpretation of that word.
The collegium is judge-made; the executive's procedure is set out in a Memorandum of Procedure.
Four Judges cases
Step 1
1981 · First Judges case (S.P. Gupta)
- 'Consultation' does not mean concurrence
- Executive primacy in appointments
Step 2
1993 · Second Judges case (SC Advocates-on-Record Association)
- Overruled S.P. Gupta; CJI's opinion has primacy
- CJI to decide with his two senior-most colleagues — the collegium is born
Step 3
1998 · Third Judges case (Presidential reference)
- Collegium enlarged to CJI + four senior-most judges for Supreme Court appointments
Step 4
2015 · Fourth Judges case (NJAC)
- 99th Amendment and NJAC Act struck down 4:1
- Primacy of the judiciary held part of judicial independence and the basic structure
Who sits in which collegium
| Purpose | Members |
|---|---|
| Supreme Court appointments | CJI + four senior-most Supreme Court judges |
| High Court judges' transfers | CJI + four senior-most Supreme Court judges |
| High Court appointments (at Supreme Court level) | CJI + two senior-most Supreme Court judges |
| High Court recommendations (initiation) | High Court Chief Justice + two senior-most High Court judges |
Collegium vs the proposed NJAC
Collegium
In force
- Only judges recommend
- Government may return a name once; a reiterated name is ordinarily accepted
- Criticised for opacity
NJAC (2014)
Struck down
- CJI + two senior-most judges + Union Law Minister + two eminent persons
- Eminent persons chosen by the PM, CJI and Leader of Opposition
- Any two members could veto — seen as diluting judicial primacy
The Court kept the collegium but acknowledged the need to improve its transparency.
Prelims traps
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
The collegium system is provided in Article 124.
It was evolved by the Judges cases; the Constitution speaks only of 'consultation'.
The NJAC was created by an ordinary law alone.
The 99th Amendment (2014) inserted Article 124A; the NJAC Act set out the procedure.
The First Judges case created the collegium.
The Second Judges case (1993) did.
Prelims focus
- Sequence of Judges cases
- NJAC composition
- Collegium membership
Mains angle
- Critically evaluate the collegium system and suggest reforms that preserve judicial independence while improving accountability.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.The NJAC was declared unconstitutional in:
Q2.Which of the following was NOT a member of the proposed NJAC?
Q3.In S.P. Gupta (1981), the Supreme Court held that 'consultation' means:
