Article 323A vs Article 323B
Article 323A
Administrative tribunals
- Recruitment and service conditions of public servants
- Only Parliament can create them
- No hierarchy of tribunals
- Example: CAT under the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985
Article 323B
Other matters
- Taxation, foreign exchange, industrial and labour disputes, land reforms, elections, rent and tenancy and more
- Parliament and State legislatures can create them
- A hierarchy may be created
Courts vs tribunals
| Feature | Courts | Tribunals |
|---|---|---|
| Created by | The Constitution and judicial laws | Statutes under Arts 323A/323B or other laws |
| Jurisdiction | General | Specialised |
| Procedure | Formal codes | Flexible, natural justice |
| Members | Judges | Judicial and expert (technical) members |
| Subject to HC review |
How the law evolved
Step 1
1976 · 42nd Amendment
- Part XIV-A inserted on the Swaran Singh Committee's advice
Step 2
1987 · S.P. Sampath Kumar
- Tribunals accepted as effective substitutes for High Courts
Step 3
1997 · L. Chandra Kumar
- Clauses excluding Articles 226/32 struck down; judicial review is basic structure
- Tribunal decisions go before a High Court division bench
- Tribunals supplement, not replace, High Courts; they cannot rule on their own parent Act
Step 4
2021 · Tribunals Reforms Act
- Several appellate tribunals abolished and their work moved to High Courts
- Provisions on tenure and service repeatedly challenged in the Madras Bar Association cases
Major tribunals
CAT
- Service matters of Union employees — 1985
NGT
- Environmental cases — NGT Act, 2010
NCLT / NCLAT
- Company and insolvency matters — set up in 2016
Armed Forces Tribunal
- Service matters of the armed forces — 2007 Act
ITAT
- Income-tax appeals — India's oldest tribunal (1941)
SAT
- Appeals against SEBI and other financial regulators
Prelims traps
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
L. Chandra Kumar held that tribunals are part of the basic structure.
It held that judicial review by High Courts and the Supreme Court is part of the basic structure.
State legislatures can create administrative tribunals under 323A.
Only Parliament can; States may create tribunals under 323B.
Tribunal decisions can go straight to the Supreme Court only.
After L. Chandra Kumar they lie before a High Court division bench first, unless a law provides a direct appeal.
Prelims focus
- 323A vs 323B
- L. Chandra Kumar
- Tribunal–Act matching
Mains angle
- Tribunalisation of justice has been both a solution and a problem. Discuss.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.The National Green Tribunal was set up under an Act of:
Q2.Which statement about Article 323B is correct?
Q3.In L. Chandra Kumar, the Supreme Court held that tribunals:
