Unlike the President, the Governor is expressly given discretion. Article 163(1) says ministers advise him 'except in so far as he is by or under this Constitution required to exercise his functions in his discretion', and Article 163(2) makes his own decision on whether a matter is discretionary final. Courts have nonetheless held that discretion is narrow and reviewable.
Discretion is a constitutional duty, not a personal preference.
Two kinds of discretion
Constitutional (written)
- Reserving a Bill for the President (Art 200)
- Recommending President's Rule (Art 356)
- Acting as administrator of an adjoining Union Territory (Art 239(2))
- Royalty shares from mineral licences under the Sixth Schedule (Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura, Mizoram)
- Seeking information from the CM (Art 167)
Situational (unwritten)
- Choosing a CM when no party has a majority
- Choosing a CM when an incumbent dies suddenly
- Dismissing a ministry that refuses to face a floor test after losing majority
- Dissolving the Assembly when the ministry has lost majority
Special responsibilities under Article 371
Maharashtra & Gujarat
- Development boards for Vidarbha, Marathwada, Saurashtra and Kutch — Art 371(2)
Nagaland & Arunachal
- Law and order — Arts 371A and 371H
Manipur, Sikkim, Karnataka
- Hill Areas committee (371C)
- Peace and equitable development (371F)
- Kalyana-Karnataka board (371J)
Sarkaria order of preference in a hung Assembly
1 · Pre-poll alliance
An alliance formed before the election that commands a majority.
2 · Largest party
The single largest party claiming support of others, including independents.
3 · Post-poll coalition
A post-election coalition with all partners joining the government.
4 · Outside support
A post-election alliance with some partners supporting from outside.
Floor test
Whoever is invited must prove majority on the floor of the House — S.R. Bommai (1994).
Judicial limits on discretion
Step 1
1994 · S.R. Bommai
- Majority is tested on the floor, not in Raj Bhavan
- Proclamations under Article 356 are open to judicial review
Step 2
2006 · Rameshwar Prasad
- Dissolution of the Bihar Assembly in 2005 held unconstitutional
- The Governor cannot pre-empt government formation on unverified fears
Step 3
2016 · Nabam Rebia
- Governor cannot advance or summon a session on his own against ministerial advice
- Article 163 discretion is limited to what the Constitution specifies
Step 4
2020 · Shivraj Singh Chouhan
- Governor may call a floor test if the ministry prima facie appears to have lost majority
Step 5
2023 · Subhash Desai
- Calling the 2022 Maharashtra floor test lacked objective material
- Intra-party disputes are no ground for a floor test
Prelims traps
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
The President and the Governor both have express constitutional discretion.
Only the Governor's discretion is expressly mentioned (Art 163); the President has situational discretion only.
The Governor's discretion cannot be questioned in court.
His decision on whether a matter is discretionary is final under Art 163(2), but its exercise is reviewable for mala fides and irrelevance (Bommai, Nabam Rebia).
Prelims focus
- Constitutional vs situational discretion
- Article 371 States
- Case–principle matching
Mains angle
- 'The Governor's discretion is a safety valve, not a parallel executive.' Examine with recent judgments.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which of the following is a constitutional (not situational) discretion of the Governor?
Q2.In Nabam Rebia (2016), the Supreme Court held that the Governor:
Q3.The Governor's discretion over royalty shares from mineral licences relates to:
