Two views of the office
Link and guardian
- Keeps the Union informed about the State
- Ensures continuity during political crises
- Upholds the Constitution when a ministry acts unconstitutionally
- Speaks for special regions under Article 371 and the Sixth Schedule
Agent of the Centre
- Appointed and removable by the Union government
- Partisan use of Article 356 before 1994
- Controversial choices in hung Assemblies
- Long delays over State Bills
The office is meant to be impartial; its legitimacy depends on restraint and convention.
What the commissions recommended
| Body | Year | Key recommendations |
|---|---|---|
| Administrative Reforms Commission | 1969 | Appoint persons of long public life and administrative experience; act non-partisanly |
| Rajamannar Committee (Tamil Nadu) | 1971 | Delete Articles 356 and 357; Governor should not be a mere nominee of the Union |
| Sarkaria Commission | 1988 | Eminent outsider, not recently active in politics; consult the CM; complete the five-year term barring compelling reasons; Article 356 only as last resort |
| NCRWC (Venkatachaliah) | 2002 | Appointment after consulting the CM; decide on Bills within a time limit |
| Punchhi Commission | 2010 | Fixed five-year tenure; removal by a resolution of the State Legislature; Governor should not be university chancellor; time limit of six months for decisions on Bills |
Current flashpoints
Assent to Bills
- Pending Bills led to Supreme Court cases from Punjab, Kerala and Tamil Nadu
- Answered by the 2023 Punjab ruling and the 2025 Presidential Reference
University chancellorship
- The Governor is chancellor under State laws, not the Constitution
- Several States have moved Bills to give the role to others
Address to the House
- Disputes over Governors skipping portions of the government-prepared address
- The address is the ministry's policy statement under Article 176
Article 356 reports
- Used over 100 times since 1950
- Sharply reduced after S.R. Bommai made it reviewable
Prelims traps
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
The Constitution makes the Governor the chancellor of State universities.
Chancellorship comes from State university laws, which legislatures can amend.
The Sarkaria Commission recommended abolishing the Governor's office.
It recommended reforming appointments and restraint, not abolition.
The Punchhi Commission proposed that the President alone remove Governors.
It proposed removal through a resolution of the State Legislature.
Prelims focus
- Commission–recommendation matching
Mains angle
- Is the office of the Governor relevant in a mature federal democracy? Critically examine in the light of the Sarkaria and Punchhi recommendations.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.The recommendation that a Governor should be 'an outsider not recently active in politics' came from:
Q2.Removal of the Governor through a resolution of the State Legislature was proposed by:
Q3.Governors act as chancellors of State universities by virtue of:
