Applied ethical judgement is not the mechanical insertion of a thinker’s name into a file note. It requires domain knowledge: clinical prognosis, ecological risk, model error or corporate incentives can change what a defensible decision demands. Officials must also identify who has authority to decide and who can seek correction.
Ethical analysis supplements applicable law and professional standards; it does not authorise officers to improvise medical consent or waive environmental duties.
Concept diagram
Governance is where theories meet real lives
Different domains expose different harms, duties and power imbalances. Translate a principle into safeguards, reasons, accountability and review.
- Different domains expose different harms, duties and power imbalances.
- Translate a principle into safeguards, reasons, accountability and review.
Four domains, four sets of operational safeguards
| Domain | Ethical tension | Safeguard |
|---|---|---|
| Bioethics | Autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice may conflict | Valid informed consent, appropriate clinical assessment and safeguards for vulnerable patients. |
| Environment | Present development can impose irreversible future costs | Precaution, prevention, polluter responsibility and assessment of cumulative and intergenerational effects. |
| Technology and AI | Efficient prediction may compromise privacy, equality and explanation | Data minimisation, tested performance, meaningful human review and accessible challenge. |
| Business and contracting | Profit or speed can displace safety and fiduciary responsibility | Conflict disclosure, independent verification, transparent procurement and enforceable accountability. |
Indian legal anchors: state the limited proposition
| Anchor | What it establishes for this discussion | Avoid claiming |
|---|---|---|
| Aruna Ramachandra Shanbaug v. Union of India (2011) | Addressed withdrawal of life support and prescribed safeguards in the legal position then prevailing. | That it legalised active euthanasia. |
| Common Cause v. Union of India (2018) | Recognised advance directives and the right to die with dignity in its end-of-life context, with safeguards; procedures were modified in 2023. | That a wish to die creates unrestricted authority to cause death. |
| M. C. Mehta v. Union of India, Oleum Gas Leak case (1986) | Developed absolute liability for enterprises engaged in hazardous or inherently dangerous activities. | That every environmental dispute has identical facts or a single automatic remedy. |
Original vignette: an automated welfare fraud flag
Risk and evidence
- A district dashboard flags households sharing a phone number as suspected duplicates. A supervisor proposes automatic suspension to save money; field staff report that neighbours often share phones.
- A risk indicator is not a finding of fraud. Wrongful exclusion can remove essential support, while unchecked duplication can divert public funds.
Proportionate intervention
- Validate the signal against verified samples, require authorised individual review and offer accessible notice and correction procedures consistent with the scheme. Do not make a shared phone number conclusive.
- Limit access to personal data, record overrides and track false positives alongside recovered funds. Maintain support or interim protection where applicable rules require it.
Turn a principle into an auditable safeguard
Identify authority
Separate a policy preference from a legal power and name the responsible decision-maker.
Test the evidence
Examine error rates, uncertainty, alternatives and who is absent from the dataset or consultation.
Protect people
Build consent, access, safety or privacy protections suited to the domain.
Correct and learn
Provide review, monitor distributional effects and alter the intervention when evidence warrants.
Distinctions that prevent weak answers
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Cost-benefit analysis settles every policy question.
It informs comparison but cannot alone determine rights, consent or a fair distribution of burdens.
Human review means a person clicks approve.
Review must be competent and meaningful, with information and authority to challenge an automated recommendation.
Future generations cannot complain, so their interests are optional.
Intergenerational equity requires attention to long-term resources, irreversible damage and inherited risks.
Prelims focus
- Distinguish withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment under safeguards from active euthanasia.
- Know the Oleum Gas Leak decision’s absolute-liability principle without confusing it with ordinary negligence.
Mains angle
- PYQ-style: Explain why a high-accuracy AI system can still be ethically unacceptable in public administration.
- For an environmental case, distinguish compensation for damage from preventing avoidable irreversible harm.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Common Cause (2018) is associated with:
Q2.A welfare model’s shared-phone flag should normally trigger:
Q3.Which best operationalises intergenerational equity?
