In a timed answer, identify the contested act and the person who bears its burden before reaching for a theory. Then use the theory’s actual test: universalisation is not popularity, welfare is not a headcount, virtue is not reputation, and justice is not identical treatment.
The chapter’s lenses can inform one decision while retaining genuine disagreements about priority and permissible sacrifice.
Concept diagram
Recall the question—not just the thinker
Do not equate utility with selfishness, or virtue with a mechanical midpoint. Name the lens, apply it to facts, state its limits and justify your judgement.
- Do not equate utility with selfishness, or virtue with a mechanical midpoint.
- Name the lens, apply it to facts, state its limits and justify your judgement.
Thinker–concept retrieval grid
| Thinker or tradition | Retrieve | Do not confuse with |
|---|---|---|
| Kant; Groundwork (1785) | Good will; categorical imperative; humanity as an end | Blind obedience to any official order. |
| Bentham; Introduction (1789) | Utility; intensity, duration and other dimensions of pleasure and pain | Counting beneficiaries without measuring effects. |
| Mill; On Liberty (1859), Utilitarianism (1861) | Harm principle; qualitative distinctions among pleasures | Treating offence alone as sufficient harm or all pleasure as equal. |
| Aristotle; Nicomachean Ethics | Eudaimonia, habituation, mean and phronesis | A midpoint between justice and injustice. |
| W. D. Ross; The Right and the Good (1930) | Prima facie duties remain morally significant though one may be outweighed | Duties that are merely apparent or optional. |
| Rawls; A Theory of Justice (1971) | Original position, veil, liberties, opportunity, difference principle | Maximum aggregate happiness. |
| Gilligan; In a Different Voice (1982) | Care, relationships and contextual responsibility | A licence for nepotism. |
| Sen; The Idea of Justice (2009) | Capabilities and realised justice; niti–nyaya distinction | Institutional design or resources as the entire measure of justice. |
Indian ideas in one conceptual pass
- Gita: disciplined action without attachment to personal fruits; lokasangraha connects conduct with sustaining collective life.
- Buddhist cultivation addresses suffering; Jain ahimsa and anekantavada combine restraint with humility about perspective.
- Gandhi links moral means and ends; trusteeship stresses social responsibility in the holding of wealth.
- Kautilya and Thiruvalluvar offer distinct reflections on responsible rule; neither should be compressed into an invented quotation.
Compare tests on one action
| Lens | Decisive question | Necessary caution |
|---|---|---|
| Duty | What obligation or constraint applies? | Identify conflicts; distinguish moral duty from a superior’s instruction. |
| Consequences | Which feasible option yields the best expected outcome? | Include uncertainty, duration and distribution, not only immediate benefit. |
| Virtue | What response expresses practical wisdom and good character? | Translate the virtue into observable conduct. |
| Justice | Can the allocation be justified on fair terms? | Check liberty, opportunity and burdens on the disadvantaged. |
| Care | Whose vulnerability or dependence is unseen? | Respond through defensible criteria, not personal preference. |
Original revision drill: an overstated school-meal report
Spot the problem
- A block officer discovers that the month’s nutrition dashboard counts meals on days when two schools were closed for repairs. Staff request silence because correction may damage the district ranking.
- This is not a genuine clash between honesty and public welfare if the claimed welfare consists only of retaining a misleading rank. Actual missed nutrition still requires attention.
Build a multi-lens response
- Verify attendance and supply records, correct the figures through the prescribed process and investigate causes without presuming individual guilt. Assess whether children missed support and arrange lawful remedial measures.
- Duty rejects false certification; consequences reveal planning harms; virtue supports candour; justice prioritises affected children; care asks whether households can access the remedy.
Memory aid
A revision aid: LENS
“Locate, Examine, Name, Safeguard — an original recall aid, not a philosophical theory.”
- LLocate the level: descriptive, meta-ethical, normative or applied.
- EExamine facts, affected people and feasible alternatives.
- NName the precise test and explain what it changes.
- SSafeguard rights and access; specify review and residual harm.
Distinctions that prevent weak answers
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Act and rule utilitarianism mean selfishness versus altruism.
Both concern welfare; they differ over whether particular acts or acceptance of rules supplies the relevant evaluation.
Theories are always complementary.
They can conflict over rights, aggregation and special responsibilities; explain priorities rather than concealing disagreement.
A culturally accepted practice is thereby justified.
Descriptive acceptance and moral justification are different questions.
A quotation makes an answer philosophical.
A correctly applied concept with evidence is stronger than an unverified or decorative quotation.
Prelims focus
- Self-test: explain Hume, Moore and Ayer without using the word “subjective” as a catch-all.
- Recall one distinction each: hypothetical/categorical, act/rule, resources/capabilities, equality/equity.
Mains angle
- PYQ-style: Can desirable outcomes justify wrongful means? Compare Kant, utilitarianism and Gandhi, then state your defended position.
- PYQ-style: Explain how care can enrich justice without undermining impartial public service.
- Case-answer audit: identify the decision, its authority, the reason for rejecting alternatives and a measurable review trigger.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which pairing is incorrect?
Q2.Ross’s prima facie duty is best described as:
Q3.The strongest revision answer to the meal-report case would:
