Normative ethics asks how we ought to act and live. Deontology tests duties and constraints, consequentialism evaluates outcomes, and virtue ethics examines excellent character and practical wisdom; each offers a different account of what makes conduct right or admirable.
These are broad families, not internally uniform doctrines. Utilitarianism is one consequentialist family; Kantian ethics is one deontological account; Aristotle is central but not exhaustive of virtue ethics.
Concept diagram
One action, three sites of judgement
Deontology tests duties; consequentialism evaluates effects. Virtue ethics asks what practical wisdom and good character require.
- Deontology tests duties; consequentialism evaluates effects.
- Virtue ethics asks what practical wisdom and good character require.
Locate the primary ground of judgement
Duty and constraints
- Some actions are impermissible even when they promise aggregate gains, because persons have claims that others must respect.
- Administrative question: may officials deceive applicants or bypass a fair hearing simply to clear a backlog?
Consequences and welfare
- Assess the effects of available options on everyone affected, including indirect effects and future risks.
- Administrative question: which feasible arrangement most reduces serious harm, rather than merely improving a visible output?
Character and judgement
- A good decision expresses virtues such as justice, honesty and courage, informed by practical wisdom in the circumstances.
- Administrative question: what would a responsible officer notice, feel and do, including when supervision is absent?
Same feature, different ethical significance
| Feature | Duty-based reading | Consequentialist reading | Virtue-based reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Honest reporting | An obligation owed to those entitled to the truth | Supports reliable decisions and institutional trust | Expresses truthfulness and integrity |
| Intention | Central to Kantian moral worth; not identical to mere compliance | Usually relevant through consequences, prediction or assessment of agents | Helps reveal stable motivation and character |
| Rules | Can express binding duties or constraints | May be justified by beneficial acceptance and practice | Guide action, but wise judgement resists mechanical application |
| Outcome uncertainty | Does not erase duties | Requires expected effects, probabilities and sensitivity tests | Calls for practical judgement, humility and willingness to learn |
Convergence is possible; foundations still differ
Same action
- Three officials may all reject a bribe.
- One respects duty, another protects public welfare, and another acts from settled integrity.
Different evaluation
- Identical visible conduct does not establish identical motivation or moral justification.
- When honesty is costly, these underlying reasons may lead to different judgements about exceptions.
Explain the reason for the action, not merely which thinker would approve the result.
Original vignette: inflated skill-training completions
A district programme can retain its next grant if a spreadsheet records people who enrolled but never completed training as successful graduates.
Duty lens
False certification violates truthful reporting and deprives decision-makers of information they are entitled to use. Grant retention is not a permission to fabricate.
Consequence lens
Count the immediate funding risk alongside misallocated money, poor trainee support, audit exposure and deterioration of data used for future policy.
Character lens
Integrity requires owning the shortfall rather than rewarding appearances; courage must be paired with practical steps to protect trainees.
Reasoned action
Submit accurate figures, explain causes, seek permissible remedial training and funding revision, and institute attendance verification without coercing false signatures.
Distinctions that protect the argument
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Deontology ignores every consequence.
It denies that maximising outcomes is the sole basis of rightness; many deontologists consider consequences within constraints.
Virtue ethics means doing whatever a nice person feels.
Virtue involves trained dispositions and practical wisdom, not unexamined sympathy or personal charm.
Prelims focus
- Consequentialism is broader than utilitarianism.
- Distinguish right action, good outcome and admirable agent: they are related but not identical evaluations.
Mains angle
- PYQ-style: Compare the ethical grounds for truthful reporting under the three approaches.
- When lenses conflict, identify lawful constraints first, then explain how welfare and practical wisdom guide choices within them.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which pairing is correctly nested?
Q2.The strongest virtue-ethical question is:
Q3.Three officers reject a bribe for different reasons. This shows that:
