A policy may increase total welfare yet remain unfair to those who bear its costs. Justice asks how terms of cooperation are justified; rights ask what others owe each person; care asks whose dependence and voice are being overlooked. These approaches overlap without becoming interchangeable.
Use constitutional rights as binding public standards; philosophical theories help evaluate and improve policy, not suspend legal entitlements.
Real pictures
Social contract and justice
Thinkers who explained political authority and justice through agreement among free people, and a modern Indian voice on justice as lived outcomes.
Thomas Hobbes (1588–1679)
In Leviathan (1651) Hobbes argued that people accept a sovereign to escape a ‘war of all against all’.
Image: John Michael Wright · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
John Locke (1632–1704)
His Two Treatises of Government (1689) defended natural rights to life, liberty and property and government by consent.
Image: Godfrey Kneller · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712–1778)
The Social Contract (1762) grounded legitimate authority in the ‘general will’ of citizens.
Image: Maurice Quentin de La Tour (Life time: 1788) · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
Amartya Sen (b. 1933)
In The Idea of Justice (2009) Sen contrasted niti (rules and institutions) with nyaya (justice as realised in people’s lives) and developed the capability approach.
Image: Amartya_Sen_20071128_cologne.jpg: Elke Wetzig (Elya) derivative work: ChaudhryAzan (talk) · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons
Concept diagram
Choose the rules before knowing your place
Rawls’s veil hides social position—not general facts about society. Rights protect claims; care notices dependency and lived relationships.
- Rawls’s veil hides social position—not general facts about society.
- Rights protect claims; care notices dependency and lived relationships.
Social contract is not one doctrine
| Thinker | Central problem and answer | Useful caution |
|---|---|---|
| Hobbes | Insecurity motivates a covenant establishing sovereign authority for peace. | Security reasoning must not be mistaken for a complete contemporary rights framework. |
| Locke | Government exists to protect natural rights, including life, liberty and property, through consent. | Limited government differs from an unrestricted power to maximise welfare. |
| Rousseau | Legitimate political association expresses a general will oriented towards the common good. | The general will is not simply whatever a temporary majority desires. |
Rawls: constructing fair terms, not conducting an opinion poll
Original position
Imagine free and equal representatives selecting principles for society’s basic structure.
Veil of ignorance
Exclude knowledge of personal class, talents and social position, while retaining general facts about society.
Ordered principles
Equal basic liberties have priority; fair equality of opportunity precedes the difference principle within the second principle.
Difference principle
Social and economic inequalities must work to the greatest benefit of the least advantaged; this is not a licence to sacrifice basic liberties.
Three correctives to a distribution-only answer
Robert Nozick
Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974)
Entitlement theory evaluates holdings through just acquisition, transfer and rectification, rather than a prescribed end-state distribution.
Amartya Sen
Capabilities; The Idea of Justice (2009)
Look at substantive freedoms and actual lives, not only resources. His niti–nyaya distinction contrasts institutional propriety with realised justice.
Carol Gilligan
In a Different Voice (1982)
Care highlights relationships, responsibility and context. It should not be reduced to a claim that all women reason alike or that men cannot care.
Original vignette: allocating accessible legal-aid appointments
Formal equality conceals exclusion
- A district legal-aid office offers identical online appointment windows. People requiring sign-language interpretation cannot use most slots; informal workers lose wages waiting for assistance.
- An equal number of slots does not secure equal practical opportunity to obtain help. Rights, capabilities and care expose different dimensions of this failure.
Fair redesign
- Maintain transparent eligibility while providing accessible booking, interpreter coordination and predictable appointment times. Consult affected users rather than assuming what assistance they need.
- Monitor waiting times and successful access by group. Additional support responds to relevant disadvantage; it is not a private favour to a preferred applicant.
Distinctions that prevent weak answers
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Rawls advocates equal income regardless of circumstances.
His principles permit inequalities only under demanding conditions, including benefit to the least advantaged and fair opportunity.
Care means ignoring impartial standards for someone sympathetic.
Care can improve how a universal entitlement is delivered while transparent criteria prevent favouritism.
Sen’s capabilities are the same as cash holdings.
People differ in converting resources into real opportunities because of disability, social barriers and other circumstances.
Prelims focus
- Place A Theory of Justice in 1971 and distinguish the veil from actual ignorance.
- Remember that Rawls’s difference principle is not Bentham’s aggregate welfare rule.
Mains angle
- PYQ-style: Why can identical treatment reproduce injustice? Use capabilities and accessible public services.
- Contrast a rights floor, fair distribution and relational care before defending a policy choice.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which proposal conflicts most directly with Rawls’s priority of basic liberties?
Q2.A capability assessment primarily asks:
Q3.Care ethics most usefully adds:
