1975–1981: the doctrine survives
Jun 1975
Allahabad High Court
Sets aside Indira Gandhi's 1971 election.
Aug 1975
39th Amendment
Art 329A puts the PM's election beyond courts.
Nov 1975
Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain
Art 329A(4) struck down — free and fair elections are basic.
Nov 1975
Review bench dissolved
A 13-judge bench to reconsider Kesavananda was disbanded after two days.
1976
42nd Amendment
Art 368(4), (5); Art 31C widened to all directives.
1980
Minerva Mills
Clauses (4), (5) void; FR–DPSP balance is basic.
1981
Waman Rao
Ninth Schedule cut-off: 24 April 1973.
Minerva Mills (1980) — three lessons
Limited power
- Parliament cannot convert a limited power into an unlimited one
- Limited amending power is itself a basic feature
Judicial review
- Excluding courts from reviewing amendments destroys the basic structure
Harmony
- Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles must be balanced; neither can be sacrificed wholesale
Waman Rao's dividing line
Before 24 April 1973
- Laws added to the Ninth Schedule are protected
- Cannot be challenged for violating Fundamental Rights
On or after 24 April 1973
- Additions are open to basic-structure review
- Confirmed and developed in I.R. Coelho (2007)
24 April 1973 — the date of Kesavananda — is the cut-off.
Often confused
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
The 44th Amendment repealed Article 368(4) and (5).
They were struck down by the Supreme Court in Minerva Mills; Parliament did not repeal them.
Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain upheld the 39th Amendment entirely.
It struck down clause (4) of Art 329A, which validated the election.
Prelims focus
- 39th Amendment and Art 329A
- Minerva Mills holdings
- Waman Rao cut-off date
Mains angle
- How did the Emergency period test the basic structure doctrine? Discuss with cases.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which amendment placed the election of the Prime Minister beyond judicial scrutiny?
Q2.Laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after which date are open to basic-structure review?
Q3.Minerva Mills (1980) is associated with:
