A rigid constitution needs a special, harder procedure to change; a flexible one changes like ordinary law. India mixes the two — the hardness of the procedure depends on which provision is being changed.
USA vs UK vs India
| Feature | USA | UK | India |
|---|---|---|---|
| Written, single document | |||
| Special amending procedure | For most provisions | ||
| Ordinary law can change some provisions | |||
| States take part in amendment | Always (¾ of States) | No States | Only federal provisions (½ of States) |
| Courts can strike down an amendment | Yes — basic structure |
In the UK, Parliament is sovereign and courts cannot invalidate an Act of Parliament; in India, the Constitution is supreme.
Two ends of the spectrum
Rigid — USA
Article V
- Proposed by two-thirds of both Houses of Congress (or a convention)
- Ratified by three-fourths of the States
- 27 amendments in over two centuries
Flexible — UK
Uncodified
- No single written constitution
- Parliament changes constitutional law by ordinary majority
- Parliamentary sovereignty, not constitutional supremacy
India: rigid where the federation is affected, flexible where only Parliament's own arrangements are concerned.
Where India sits
Flexible part
- Simple majority, outside Art 368
- e.g., new States, Legislative Councils, quorum
Middle part
- Special majority of both Houses
- e.g., Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles
Rigid part
- Special majority + half the States
- e.g., election of President, Seventh Schedule
Often confused
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
In India, Parliament alone amends the Constitution; States have no role at all.
Federal provisions listed in the proviso to Art 368(2) need ratification by at least half of the State Legislatures.
States can propose amendments, as in the US.
Only Parliament can initiate an Article 368 amendment; a State Assembly can only ratify.
Prelims focus
- USA ¾ States vs India ½ States
- Parliamentary sovereignty vs constitutional supremacy
Mains angle
- Compare the amending procedures of India, the USA and the UK. What does India's choice reveal about its federalism?
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.The Indian Constitution is best described as:
Q2.In India, ratification by States is required for amendments that affect:
Q3.Which country follows the principle of parliamentary sovereignty?
