The line Parliament cannot cross
Parliament CAN
- Amend any Article, Schedule or the Preamble
- Abridge or remove a Fundamental Right — e.g., property (44th, 1978)
- Add new rights — e.g., education (86th, 2002)
- Reorganise States, change taxing powers, create new institutions
- Change the structure of courts and tribunals
Parliament CANNOT
- Destroy democracy, free and fair elections or the republican form
- Abolish judicial review or judicial independence
- Make its own amending power unlimited
- Destroy secularism, federalism or the rule of law
- Wipe out the essence of equality, liberty and dignity
Amend — yes. Destroy the identity — no.
Quick check: is this amendment permissible?
| Feature | Permissible? |
|---|---|
| Adding 'socialist' and 'secular' to the Preamble (42nd) | |
| Removing the right to property from Part III (44th) | |
| Putting an election beyond any court (39th, Art 329A(4)) | |
| Barring courts from reviewing amendments (Art 368(4)) | |
| 10% EWS reservation (103rd) | |
| Executive-majority panel to appoint judges (99th) |
Based on what courts actually decided in Kesavananda, Raj Narain, Minerva Mills, the NJAC case and Janhit Abhiyan.
How courts apply the test
- Identify the feature the amendment touches
- Ask whether it is a basic feature recognised by courts
- Test the effect: does the amendment damage or destroy that feature's identity?
- If not, the amendment stands even if it changes the feature
Often confused
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Parliament cannot take away or dilute any Fundamental Right.
It can amend Fundamental Rights; the right to property was removed in 1978. Only their essential core is protected.
The Preamble cannot be amended.
Kesavananda held it amendable (subject to basic structure); the 42nd Amendment did so in 1976.
Ordinary laws are struck down for violating the basic structure.
The test is mainly applied to constitutional amendments; ordinary laws are usually tested against specific Articles.
Prelims focus
- Preamble amendable — once, by the 42nd
- Property right removal valid
Mains angle
- 'The amending power is wide but not unlimited.' Explain with examples of permissible and impermissible amendments.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Which of these amendments would violate the basic structure?
Q2.The Preamble of the Constitution:
Q3.Which statement is correct?
