The question was simple: is a constitutional amendment a 'law' under Article 13? If yes, any amendment that takes away a Fundamental Right is void. The Supreme Court changed its answer within sixteen years.
Phase one of the battle
Step 1
1951 · Shankari Prasad v Union of India
- Challenge to the 1st Amendment (Arts 31A, 31B, Ninth Schedule)
- 'Law' in Art 13 means ordinary law, not an amendment
- Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights
Step 2
1965 · Sajjan Singh v State of Rajasthan
- Upheld the 17th Amendment (more land laws in the Ninth Schedule)
- Majority followed Shankari Prasad
- Justices Hidayatullah and Mudholkar doubted — Mudholkar asked whether 'basic features' could be changed
Step 3
1967 · I.C. Golaknath v State of Punjab
- Eleven judges, 6:5, Chief Justice K. Subba Rao
- Fundamental Rights have a 'transcendental' position — Parliament cannot abridge them
- An amendment is 'law' under Art 13; Art 368 gives only procedure
Step 4
1971 · 24th Amendment
- Parliament's reply: Art 13(4), Art 368(3) and 'constituent power'
- Power to amend any part, including Part III
Golaknath — the clever escape
Prospective overruling
- The ruling applied only to the future
- Earlier amendments (1st, 4th, 17th) and land reforms stayed valid
Source of power
- Majority said amending power came from residuary law-making power (Art 248, Entry 97 of the Union List), not Art 368
Often confused
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Golaknath introduced the basic structure doctrine.
Golaknath held Fundamental Rights unamendable; basic structure came in Kesavananda (1973).
Shankari Prasad was decided after the 24th Amendment.
It was decided in 1951, upholding the 1st Amendment.
Prelims focus
- Case–year–holding matching
- Golaknath bench size and prospective overruling
Mains angle
- How did the debate over amending Fundamental Rights evolve between 1951 and 1971?
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.In which case did the Supreme Court hold that Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights?
Q2.The doctrine of prospective overruling was first applied by the Supreme Court in:
Q3.Which judge in Sajjan Singh raised the question of 'basic features'?
