For two decades Parliament and the Supreme Court disagreed on one question: is a constitutional amendment a 'law' that Article 13 can strike down?
The amendability debate
1951
Shankari Prasad
Parliament can amend any part, including Fundamental Rights; an amendment is not 'law' under Article 13.
1965
Sajjan Singh
Same view repeated.
1967
Golak Nath
Eleven judges, 6:5 — Fundamental Rights are 'transcendental'; Parliament cannot take them away. Prospective overruling applied for the first time.
1971
24th Amendment
Article 13(4) and 368(3): amendments are not 'law' under Article 13.
1973
Kesavananda Bharati
Thirteen judges, 7:6 — Golak Nath overruled; Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights but not the basic structure.
1980
Minerva Mills
Limited amending power and FR–DPSP harmony are themselves basic features.
2007
I.R. Coelho
Laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after 24 April 1973 can be reviewed for basic-structure violations.
Doctrines to know
Golak Nath, 1967
Prospective overruling
- A new ruling applies only to the future
- Past actions under the old view are not disturbed
Kesavananda, 1973
Basic structure
- Amending power cannot destroy the Constitution's essential features
- List grows case by case — rule of law, judicial review, federalism, secularism, free elections
Articles 13, 32, 226
Judicial review
- Courts test laws and amendments against the Constitution
- Itself a basic feature
Often confused
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Kesavananda held that Fundamental Rights cannot be amended.
That was Golak Nath. Kesavananda allowed amendment, subject to the basic structure.
Every Fundamental Right is part of the basic structure.
Only their essence, as identified case by case; individual rights can be amended.
Prelims focus
- Chronology of amendability cases
- Bench strength and majority in Golak Nath and Kesavananda
- Prospective overruling
Mains angle
- 'The basic structure doctrine has made the judiciary a co-sharer of constituent power.' Critically examine.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Arrange chronologically: 1. Kesavananda Bharati 2. Golak Nath 3. Shankari Prasad 4. Minerva Mills
Q2.The Supreme Court held that Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights in:
Q3.Which amendment responded to Golak Nath by inserting Article 13(4)?
