India is unusual among democracies in writing preventive detention into the Constitution itself — and then surrounding it with safeguards.
Article 22 has two parts: ordinary (punitive) arrest and preventive detention.
Punitive vs preventive detention
Punitive detention
- Punishes an offence already committed
- Follows trial and conviction in court
Preventive detention
- Prevents a possible future act
- No trial and no conviction
- Based on the executive's satisfaction
Rights of a person under ordinary arrest — Art 22(1)–(2)
Grounds
- Be told the grounds of arrest as soon as may be
Lawyer
- Consult and be defended by a legal practitioner of choice
Magistrate
- Be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours, excluding travel time
Release
- Not be detained beyond 24 hours without the magistrate's authority
Safeguards in preventive detention — Art 22(4)–(7)
Up to three months
Detention beyond three months needs an Advisory Board report of sufficient cause.
Advisory Board
Persons who are, have been, or are qualified to be High Court judges.
Grounds communicated
The detainee is told the grounds — facts against public interest may be withheld.
Representation
The detainee gets the earliest opportunity to represent against the order.
Parliament's power
May prescribe when detention can exceed three months without a Board, the maximum period and the Board's procedure.
Not available
22(1)–(2) do not apply to enemy aliens or persons held under preventive detention laws.
Preventive detention laws
| Law | Year | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Preventive Detention Act | 1950 | Lapsed in 1969 |
| Maintenance of Internal Security Act (MISA) | 1971 | Repealed in 1978 |
| COFEPOSA (foreign exchange & smuggling) | 1974 | In force |
| National Security Act (NSA) | 1980 | In force |
| PIT-NDPS (narcotics) | 1988 | In force |
Often confused
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Preventive detainees cannot make any representation.
Article 22(5) gives them the right to represent; only the ordinary-arrest rights of 22(1)–(2) are denied.
The 44th Amendment's two-month limit is in force.
It reduced three months to two, but that provision has not been brought into force.
Only Parliament can make preventive detention laws.
Parliament alone for defence, foreign affairs and security of India; Parliament and States both for security of a State, public order and essential supplies.
Prelims focus
- Four rights of an arrested person
- Advisory Board composition and the three-month rule
- Who can legislate on preventive detention
Mains angle
- Is preventive detention compatible with a liberal democracy? Discuss with reference to Article 22.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.An Advisory Board under Article 22 consists of persons who:
Q2.Which of the following laws is NOT a preventive detention law?
Q3.Consider: 1. A preventive detainee has the right to make a representation. 2. Preventive detention can only be ordered after a trial. Which is/are correct?
