Before asking 'which right?', ask 'against whom?'. Article 12 answers that — and Article 13 says what happens to a law that breaks the rules.
Article 12: who is the 'State'?
Union Government & Parliament
- Executive and legislative organs of the Union
State Governments & Legislatures
- Executive and legislative organs of each State
Local authorities
- Municipalities, panchayats, district boards, improvement trusts
Other authorities
- Statutory or non-statutory bodies such as LIC, ONGC, SAIL
- Any body that is an instrumentality or agency of the State (Ajay Hasia, 1981)
Article 13: what counts and what happens
Pre-constitutional laws
Void to the extent of inconsistency with Fundamental Rights (Art 13(1)).
Post-constitutional laws
The State shall not make laws that take away or abridge Fundamental Rights; such laws are void (Art 13(2)).
'Law' is wide
Acts, ordinances, orders, bye-laws, rules, regulations, notifications, customs and usages having the force of law (Art 13(3)).
Not constitutional amendments
Article 13(4), added by the 24th Amendment (1971), excludes amendments — but they remain subject to the basic structure.
Doctrines that flow from Article 13
R.M.D.C. case, 1957
Severability
- Only the offending part of a law is void
- The rest survives if it can stand on its own
Bhikaji Narain Dhakras, 1955
Eclipse
- A pre-constitutional law inconsistent with a Fundamental Right is not dead — it is overshadowed
- It revives if the right is amended to remove the conflict
Basheshar Nath, 1959
Waiver
- A citizen CANNOT waive a Fundamental Right
- The rights exist in public interest, not only for the individual
Often confused
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
The doctrine of eclipse suspends laws during an emergency.
It concerns pre-constitutional laws overshadowed by Fundamental Rights; they revive if the conflict is removed by amendment.
Fundamental Rights can be waived by consent.
Basheshar Nath (1959) held that no Fundamental Right can be waived.
Every private company is 'State' under Article 12.
Only bodies that are instrumentalities or agencies of the State — judged by tests such as funding, control and functions.
Prelims focus
- Bodies included in Article 12
- Meaning of 'law' in Article 13(3)
- Severability vs eclipse vs waiver
Mains angle
- Explain how Article 13 provides the basis of judicial review in India.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.The doctrine of eclipse applies to:
Q2.Under Article 13(3), 'law' does NOT include:
Q3.In Basheshar Nath (1959), the Supreme Court held that:
