The Constitution treats reservation not as an exception to equality but as a way to reach it — substantive equality for groups held back for generations.
Article 15 vs Article 16
Article 15
No discrimination
- Grounds: religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth
- Covers access to shops, hotels, wells, roads and public places (15(2)) — binds private persons too
- Enables special provisions in education and welfare
Article 16
Equal opportunity in public employment
- Grounds: religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth, residence
- Applies to State employment only
- Enables reservation in appointments and promotions
The enabling clauses
| Clause | What it allows | Added by |
|---|---|---|
| 15(3) | Special provisions for women and children | Original |
| 15(4) | Advancement of socially and educationally backward classes, SCs and STs | 1st Amendment, 1951 |
| 15(5) | Reservation in admissions, including private unaided institutions (not minority ones) | 93rd Amendment, 2005 |
| 15(6) & 16(6) | Up to 10% for economically weaker sections | 103rd Amendment, 2019 |
| 16(3) | Parliament may prescribe residence for certain jobs | Original |
| 16(4) | Reservation in appointments for under-represented backward classes | Original |
| 16(4A) | Reservation in promotion for SCs/STs, with consequential seniority | 77th (1995) & 85th (2001) Amendments |
| 16(4B) | Unfilled reserved vacancies carried forward outside the 50% ceiling | 81st Amendment, 2000 |
| 16(5) | Posts in religious institutions may be held by members of that religion | Original |
Reservation in the courts
1951
Champakam Dorairajan
Caste-based admissions struck down — the 1st Amendment adds Article 15(4).
1992
Indra Sawhney
27% OBC quota upheld; creamy layer excluded; 50% ceiling; no reservation in promotions (later restored for SCs/STs by amendment).
2022
Janhit Abhiyan
103rd Amendment (EWS quota) upheld 3:2.
2024
Davinder Singh
Seven-judge Bench allows States to sub-classify Scheduled Castes for reservation.
Often confused
Statements examiners like to twist — learn the correct version.
Article 15 covers discrimination in government jobs.
Public employment is Article 16; Article 15 covers access, admissions and special provisions.
'Descent' and 'residence' are grounds in Article 15.
They appear only in Article 16(2).
Reservation itself is a Fundamental Right.
Clauses like 15(4) and 16(4) are enabling — they allow the State to reserve but do not compel it.
Prelims focus
- Grounds in Articles 15 and 16
- Amendment behind each clause
- Indra Sawhney principles
Mains angle
- Does the EWS quota change the constitutional basis of reservation from social to economic backwardness? Discuss.
Flip & recall
Answer in your head first, then tap the card to check.
Practice MCQs
Original Prelims-style questions with explanations.
0 / 3 correct · 3 left
Q1.Article 15(5), permitting reservation in admissions in private unaided institutions, was inserted by the:
Q2.Consider: 1. Article 16 applies to employment under the State. 2. 'Residence' is a prohibited ground in Article 15. Which is/are correct?
Q3.The carry-forward of unfilled reserved vacancies beyond the 50% ceiling is permitted by:
